Wednesday, October 10, 2012

Fight or Flight- Marcus Garvey


After hearing about Marcus Garvey today in class, I decided to look into the work that he did for the newspapers. I found one newspaper called, Negro World that he began publishing in 1918. This was a weekly paper that included a front-page editorial written by Garvey, as well as poetry and other articles. One of his editorials that I found especially compelling was entitled, “African Fundamentalism.” This piece stresses Garvey’s belief that blacks need to regain racial self-confidence by setting aside racist labels that cause them to feel inferior. He also focuses on his belief in God, in that God and the sky should be the only limitations for blacks. Additionally, he looks back into history and emphasizes the successful accounts of African descents that currently living blacks need to strive to get back to. In short, this editorial is a very inspiring and motivational piece of writing.
            Garvey begins the editorial by saying that the time has come for Negros to take control of their lives and stop living it according to whites’ standards. He says they must realize that countless numbers of men and women have come from Africa and have lived a very successful life. So, if they can do it, why can’t anyone else? Garvey also clarifies that everyone is entitled to his or her own opinions and does not need to listen to any one else’s. He then goes on through his editorial comparing the lives of Negros to those of Jews and whites and he declares that no matter who or what you are you must represent yourself with no shame and no fear. You must be true to yourself and “’thou canst not then be false to any man.’”
            All of Garvey’s writing is very moving however it is the end of his piece that really hits me. Here, he states, “God and Nature first made us what we are, and then out of our own creative genius we make ourselves what we want to be. Follow always that great law.” Garvey reinforces the notion that people control their own destinies and motivates black to take back what have always been theirs, their lives and their self-assurance.
            Although Marcus Garvey was a proponent of, “Africa for the Africans” this editorial, in my opinion, is not necessarily a piece encouraging blacks to go to Africa. It instead, is a piece of writing encouraging, and almost ordering, Negros to gain back their self-confidence and overcome any and all stereotypes or negative banter that comes their way. I could understand why some blacks would want to go back to Africa, given all the horrible things that they had gone thorough, but in a way by doing that they would be letting the whites of the time period win. Therefore, I think it is better to stay and to fight, especially given the fact that America was their home. So, I do think that this editorial by Marcus Garvey is very powerful, but it would be even more powerful if he meant it as a reason for Negros to stay and fight. 

3 comments:

  1. Allycia, I do agree with you in your analysis of this editorial, specifically the fact that by blacks going back to Africa, they would more or less be “surrendering” and conforming to the wills of the whites of that time period. Nevertheless, if this is the case, I think this particular editorial by Garvey would be contradictory to his ideaof “Africa for the Africans.” If Garvey wants blacks to flock to Africa because of the hardships they’re experiencing in the US, then what message is he trying to convey when he encourages Negroes to “gain back their self-confidence and overcome any and all stereotypes or negative banter that comes their way,” as you aptly put it. To flock to Africa, I believe, would be to escape rather than confront and overcome the negative banter that comes their way. This is just a thought I am wrestling with in my mind.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I never thought about it like that, but that does make a lot of sense. Thanks Emmanuel for pointing that out. Obviously I was trying to figure out Garvey's opinion and take about the times, but I couldn't figure out why he would just want everyone to flee. The idea of escaping though, makes much more sense.

      Delete
  2. As an African American, Marcus Garvey’s theory that blacks should go back to Africa is hilarious. I keep try ting to picture myself in Africa and I cannot. I am an American. America is where I belong, not Africa. I do not know anything about Africa. African culture and American are totally different. So the idea of black Americans going back to Africa is obscene. I am sure several blacks felt similarly as me. Yes, our ancestors came from Africa but that was hundreds of years ago. If blacks decided to go back to Africa it would not be the same because it would be Americans going to Africa. Telling blacks to go back to Africa is the same as telling them to forget everything they know about their current culture and go back in time to their old culture. That would be a drastic change for anyone, not only blacks. I also think Marcus Garvey’s idea that black should just go back where they came from because they are not accepted in America, is telling them to give up. I cannot help but wonder what type of countries America and Africa would be today if all the black Americans would have taken Garvey’s advice and went back to Africa.

    ReplyDelete